The ESOP Trustee’s Annual Valuation Checklist: Nine Questions Every ESOP Trustee Should Ask

The ESOP Trustee’s Annual Valuation Checklist: Nine Questions Every ESOP Trustee Should Ask

An annual ESOP valuation involves more than determining a share price. It requires understanding the business, protecting employee-owners, and ensuring that the valuation process is reasonable, independent, and well-documented.

For ESOP trustees, that means asking the right questions—not simply accepting a valuation report because an expert prepared it.

  1. Are management’s financial projections realistic?
  2. Do the forecasts make sense in light of historical performance, industry conditions, and the company’s growth opportunities? If significant growth is projected, is there evidence supporting the assumptions?

  3. Is the valuation professional qualified and independent?
  4. Does the appraiser have appropriate credentials, relevant ESOP valuation experience, and the independence necessary to provide an objective opinion?

  5. Have we evaluated the company’s People, Processes, and Profits?
  6. Is the company resilient or overly dependent on key employees, customers, or processes? Are the factors driving its long-term success adequately reflected in the valuation?

  7. Are the valuation methods and assumptions reasonable?
  8. Can the appraiser explain the valuation approaches, discount rates, multiples, and significant adjustments? Are the assumptions consistent with the company’s circumstances?

  9. What changed from last year?
  10. Are changes in financial performance, share value, or valuation methodology adequately explained? Do those changes reflect developments in the business or economic environment?

  11. Have we considered the ESOP’s financial obligations?
  12. Have debt, repurchase obligations, stock options, and other ESOP-specific factors—including obligations that may not appear on the financial statements—been appropriately evaluated?

  13. Have significant business risks been adequately considered?
  14. Are customer concentration, management succession, competitive pressures, industry changes, and other material risks appropriately reflected in the projections and valuation assumptions?

  15. Do we have enough information to make an informed decision?
  16. Has the trustee received the financial information, supporting analyses, and explanations needed to evaluate the valuation? Have important questions been answered satisfactorily rather than simply deferred to the appraiser?

  17. Have we documented our review?
  18. Do the trustee’s records reflect the questions asked, explanations received, issues resolved, and reasons for accepting the final valuation?

The Bottom Line

These nine questions provide a practical starting point for an effective annual valuation review. Trustees don’t need to be valuation experts. But they do need to understand the assumptions, ask questions, and exercise independent judgment.

A well-supported valuation is important. An informed and well-documented trustee review is equally important.

Have a Question About an ESOP Valuation? Whether you’re reviewing an existing annual valuation, considering a change in valuation firms, or evaluating a new ESOP transaction, we’re happy to discuss the process and the issues trustees should consider.

Simply reply to this email to start a conversation.

This article is provided for general educational purposes and does not constitute legal, tax, or accounting advice. ESOP trustees should consult their ERISA counsel and other professional advisors regarding their specific fiduciary responsibilities.

The SBA Rules Changed – Did Your Business Value Change With Them?

The SBA Rules Changed – Did Your Business Value Change With Them?

What Uber, taxi medallions, and changing Small Business Administration lending requirements teach us about business value.

Imagine owning a New York City taxi medallion in 2013. For decades, that medallion represented something valuable: the right to operate a yellow taxi in a market where the number of medallions was tightly controlled.

Medallions traded for extraordinary prices, in some cases exceeding $1 million. Buyers weren’t simply purchasing a license. They were purchasing access to a business protected by significant barriers to entry.

Then Uber arrived.

Suddenly, customers could request a ride from their phones without hailing a cab. Technology changed how transportation services were delivered, and evolving regulations allowed new competitors to challenge the traditional taxi industry.

The result was devastating for many medallion owners. Values plummeted, leaving some owners with loans exceeding the value of their assets.

The medallions hadn’t changed. The economics of owning one had.

Sometimes the rules change, and the value of a business changes with them.

Today, buyers, sellers, lenders, and business valuation professionals are confronting another set of changing rules—this time involving Small Business Administration (SBA) financing.

Two areas deserve particular attention:  cash flow available to service acquisition debt, and the role of quality of earnings analysis. 

Now Offering Quality of Earning Reports

Art of Business Valuation is pleased to announce we are now able to prepare Quality of Earnings reports for all our SBA lenders with the addition of Trisch Garthoeffner, ABV, CVA, MAFF, EA, MAcc to our team. Trisch brings over 20+ years experience in business valuation, financial forensics and M&A advisory.

Two SBA Changes That Can Affect the Price of a Business

Effective October 1, 2026, SBA Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) 50 10 8.1 introduced important changes affecting many business acquisitions financed through the SBA 7(a) loan program.

1. Cash Flow Must Do More Than Cover the Loan Payment

The updated SBA guidelines increase the minimum debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) for many acquisitions from 1.15 to 1.25. In simple terms, a qualifying acquisition generally must demonstrate $1.25 in operating cash flow for every $1.00 of required annual debt service. Certain business expansion transactions remain subject to a 1.15 ratio. The rules also require using historical cash flow from either the last year, or the last two years averaged, and eliminate using projections for this purpose.

Consider a hypothetical business generating $250,000 in qualifying annual operating cash flow.

Illustrative comparison 1.15x coverage 1.25x coverage
Maximum annual debt service $217,391 $200,000
Loan amount at closing (10-year amortization, 10.00% interest) $1,371,000 $1,261,000
Assumptions: $250,000 qualifying annual cash flow; 120 equal monthly principal-and-interest payments; 10.00% annual interest (October 2026 illustrative SBA 7(a) variable-rate ceiling for loans over $350,000, based on 7.00% prime plus 3.00%). Loan amounts are rounded to the nearest $1,000. Actual lender rates, fees, other debt, underwriting and variable-rate adjustments may change results.

At the same assumed interest rate and repayment term, the higher coverage requirement reduces illustrative loan proceeds by approximately $110,000. That can affect the price a buyer can finance.

A seller might believe the business is worth $2 million based on historical earnings and comparable transactions. But if a prospective buyer cannot obtain enough financing to pay that amount, the seller may need to reconsider the price, financing structure, or target buyer.

A business can be worth a certain amount under a valuation methodology yet still be difficult to sell at that price under prevailing financing conditions.

2. Quality of Earnings — Proving the Profits Are Real

For qualifying initial acquisitions and business expansions with a business purchase price of $3 million or more, excluding qualifying owner-occupied real estate, the updated SBA procedures require an independent quality of earnings (QoE) analysis in addition to the business valuation.

This is significant because business owners and buyers sometimes have different views of what a company actually earns.

A seller might point to $600,000 in adjusted annual earnings after adding back personal expenses, unusual costs, and other adjustments. But how much of that $600,000 is recurring, verifiable, and available to a new owner?

A quality of earnings analysis examines the reliability and sustainability of reported earnings, including the support for proposed adjustments.  One of the most stringent requirements is tying  approximately two and a half years of bank statements into the financial statements.  If records are in poor shape this can be quite tedious.  (We recommend any business with a likely sales price over $3 million begin to obtain reviewed financial statements by an outside accountant.  This alone will make your business more salable.)

Suppose the analysis determines that only $450,000 of the seller’s claimed $600,000 in adjusted earnings is supportable. That difference could materially affect the buyer’s financing capacity and the price the buyer is willing or able to pay.

Importantly, a quality of earnings analysis is not the same as a business valuation. The former examines the quality and sustainability of earnings, while the latter develops an opinion of value based on the applicable standard of value and valuation methodologies. Both play important, complementary roles in an acquisition.

What Does This Mean for Business Owners?

The taxi medallion story illustrates how an external change can undermine assumptions that once supported substantial business value.

The SBA lending changes present a different, more nuanced situation. They do not automatically make businesses less valuable. But they may change the economics of acquiring certain businesses, particularly those whose buyers depend on SBA financing.

And for buyers, sellers, CPAs, attorneys, business brokers, and lenders, understanding these requirements and doing proper due diligence early in the transaction process may help avoid unpleasant surprises after months of negotiations.

The Bottom Line: Value Doesn’t Exist in a Vacuum

As taxi medallion owners discovered, outside forces can reshape an asset’s economic value. Similarly, SBA financing requirements can affect the prices buyers can support—even when a company’s operations remain strong.

A credible valuation considers expected cash flow, risk, and market conditions, not just last year’s earnings. At Art of Business Valuation, we focus on these factors to develop well-supported opinions of value and help owners and advisors make informed decisions.

Efficiently Use Your Gift and Estate Tax Exemption 

Efficiently Use Your Gift and Estate Tax Exemption 

A well-supported valuation can help a family transfer a closely held business while using its estate and gift tax exemption efficiently. A noncontrolling interest may be worth less than its proportionate share of the whole business because its owner cannot direct decisions or readily sell it. Making a completed gift before the business grows may also move future appreciation to the recipients. The attorney and valuator should work together before the transfer, so the ownership rights, appraisal, and gift tax reporting reflect the actual transaction:’

For 2026, the federal estate and gift tax basic exclusion amount is $15 million per person. The exclusion makes it timely for families with substantial business interests to review transfer plans. Still, the right structure depends on ownership, cash needs, governance, and the donor’s broader estate plan.

How the valuation affects the gift

A minority owner may lack the power to set distributions, appoint management, or sell company assets. Those limits can reduce value through a discount for lack of control (Investors like control). An interest in a private company may also take time and expense to sell, supporting a discount for lack of marketability. These are distinct considerations, but they must reflect the specific interest and the facts as of the gift date. There is no standard combined percentage that fits every transfer.

Suppose a company has a $22.5 million value on a controlling, marketable basis and the owner transfers all the economic interests through nonvoting units. If a properly prepared qualified appraisal supports a combined reduction of one-third for the interests transferred, their aggregate gift tax value would be $15 million. The $7.5 million difference illustrates the potential effect of the interests’ actual rights and marketability. The arithmetic alone does not establish that the discount is appropriate; the ownership structure, retained interests, governing documents, business purpose, and applicable tax rules must all be evaluated.

Why timing matters

An early gift may also move later appreciation to the recipients. If the transferred interests grow in value after a completed gift, that growth generally belongs to the recipients rather than the donor. This can be especially meaningful for a business expected to expand, though the donor also gives up the transferred economic rights. Forecasts should be supported by what was known or reasonably knowable on the valuation date.

Other estate planning techniques, including a sale to a grantor trust, can address future appreciation. They involve separate tax and legal requirements and should be considered with the estate planning attorney and tax adviser. A valuation supports the transaction by estimating fair market value; it cannot make an otherwise flawed structure effective.

Build the record before the transfer

The attorney and valuator should review the capitalization, governing documents, distribution history, transfer restrictions, financial results, and realistic paths to liquidity before the documents are signed. The valuation should identify the precise interests transferred and explain how their rights affect value. A contemporaneous, well-supported appraisal and consistent gift tax reporting give the transaction a clearer factual record if the IRS later reviews it.

The best result is a transfer that fits the family’s objectives and has a valuation the advisers can explain, and other valuators are likely to agree with. Begin with the business and the actual interest being given away; let the documented facts determine its value.

3 Common Misconceptions Borrowers Believe (and Lenders Have to Unwind)

3 Common Misconceptions Borrowers Believe (and Lenders Have to Unwind)

Securing an SBA 7(a) or a conventional bank loan to acquire or expand a small business is one of the most powerful leverage tools in commercial finance available to grow businesses. However, nothing derails an acquisition faster than a fundamental disconnect between buyer expectations and SBA or bank valuation guidelines. Lenders are often forced to perform the delicate work of unwinding those misconceptions late in the underwriting process.

Below is a breakdown of the three biggest SBA valuation and bank loan valuation myths borrowers believe—and the reality behind how most bank lenders and all SBA lenders and certified business appraisers actually evaluate deals. 

MYTH #1: “My CPA said it’s worth X.”

The Misconception:

Borrowers often enter deal discussions armed with a valuation provided by their local CPA, bookkeeper, or tax accountant. They assume that because a Certified Public Accountant handles tax returns and financial statements, their opinion of business valuation is standard and binding for bank financing.

The Reality:

Tax accounting and SBA business appraisal are completely different disciplines.

  • Specialized Accreditation Required: Under SBA guidelines (SOP 50 10 8), when an independent business valuation is required, it must be performed by a qualified independent third-party holding specific accredited valuation credentials—such as a Certified Valuation Analyst (CVA), Accredited in Business Valuation (ABV), or Accredited Senior Appraiser (ASA). Standard CPAs rarely hold these specific accreditations.  The business valuator must provide a report that meets standards.  These are usually more comprehensive than what a CPA would provide.
  • Tax Minimization vs. Enterprise Value: A tax CPA’s primary objective is tax strategy—legally minimizing taxable net income. In contrast, a business valuation appraiser focuses on normalized future cash flow and risk-adjusted enterprise value. Tax return numbers cannot simply be multiplied by a rule-of-thumb heuristic without accredited valuation methodology.

Lender and Borrower Insight: Recognize the limits of an informal CPA quote or low-level informal appraisal when structuring an offer. Recognize that a formal valuation may find different values and be ready to rework the transaction when necessary. 

MYTH #2: “The bank sets the value.”

The Misconception:

Buyers frequently believe that the bank arbitrarily chooses a valuation figure or deliberately under-appraises a business to reduce its lending risk exposure.

The Reality:

Bankers and lenders do not subjectively set valuation numbers—they enforce strict SBA regulatory requirements and rely on independent appraisers.

  • Strict SBA Mandates: Under SBA regulations, an independent third-party appraisal by a certified valuation expert is mandatory whenever the transaction value (less real estate) exceeds $250,000, or in non-arm’s length transactions (e.g., buying out a partner or family member).
  • Third-Party Independence: The appraiser operates as an independent, neutral third party. The bank cannot dictate the final value to the appraiser, nor can they arbitrarily change the appraiser’s certified valuation figure once completed.
  • Cash Flow & Debt Service Rules: Even if a valuation meets the purchase price, the lender must independently verify that the business generates sufficient cash flow to cover debt service (typically requiring a minimum 1.15x to 1.25x Debt Service Coverage Ratio / DSCR). (Increasing on October 1, 2026 to 1.25x Debt Service for acquisitions verified from prior earnings, not projections.)

Lender and Borrower Insight: The bank acts as a guardian of compliance and long-term cash flow viability, not an arbitrary price-setter. Independent third-party appraisal standards and verifiable historical cash flow determine the true ceiling on value.

 

MYTH #3: “Add-backs are unlimited.”

The Misconception:

Sellers and brokers often present long lists of proposed “add-backs” to inflate Seller’s Discretionary Earnings (SDE) or adjusted EBITDA—adding back everything from discretionary travel, auto leases, and family cell phone plans to one-time repairs and projected future growth.

The Reality:

SBA underwriters and accredited appraisers apply rigorous, conservative scrutiny to all proposed add-backs.

  • Verifiable: To be approved, an add-back must be explicitly documented on official tax returns/financial records, reasonably provable and meet strict criteria. NOTE:  the valuator cannot “guarantee” the dollar value of all ad backs as valuators are NOT auditors and do not perform buyer due diligence.  (For transactions over $3 million in value SOP 50 10 8.1 effective October 1, 2026 is going to require a quality of earnings report which is not an audit but is a reasonably comprehensive review of cash flows.)
  • Management Normalization: In determining some valuation cash flows the valuator may add back the entire owner salary and personal perks. But, in most of those cases the bank underwriter must deduct a realistic market replacement salary for a manager or the future owner to run operations post-acquisition.
  • No Speculative or Future Add-Backs: Projections, unrecorded cash revenue, or anticipated future operational synergies cannot be added back to historical earnings. SBA valuations are strictly rooted in historical, tax-verified financial performance.  If there was a doubt, the new SOP 50 10 8.1 explicitly specifies historic data is to be used.

Lender and Borrower Insight: Do not use unverified expenses to justify a higher purchase price if the deal relies on SBA loan approval—all expenses must be supported by official tax returns, invoices, or accounting records.

After 50 Years of Uncertainty, ESOP Trustees Finally Have a Safe Harbor

After 50 Years of Uncertainty, ESOP Trustees Finally Have a Safe Harbor

Since ERISA was enacted in 1974, trustees have carried the weight of a simple but frustrating question:

What exactly qualifies as “adequate consideration” when purchasing closely held company stock?

The Department of Labor never issued definitive regulations answering that question. Instead, trustees often found themselves operating in an environment many describe as “regulation by litigation,” where lawsuits, investigations, and hindsight frequently shaped expectations more than written rules.

That’s why the Retire Through Ownership Act (S.2403 / H.R.5169) is being welcomed as one of the most significant developments in ESOP history.

Rather than leaving trustees to guess where the regulatory goalposts might move next, Congress has created a statutory safe harbor that finally provides a consistent valuation framework. It doesn’t eliminate the fiduciary responsibilities—but it does provide something trustees have been asking for since the 1970s: clarity.

One Valuation Standard Instead of Moving Goalposts

One of the biggest challenges trustees have faced is the absence of a consistent definition of fair market value under ERISA.

The new law addresses that problem by amending ERISA’s definition of “adequate consideration.”

In practical terms, trustees may now rely in good faith on an independent business valuation prepared using the principles established in IRS Revenue Ruling 59-60—the valuation guidance professionals have relied on for decades.

This is important because it aligns ERISA with an already well-established IRS valuation framework. Instead of wondering whether regulators might apply a different standard years after a transaction closes, trustees now have a much clearer roadmap to follow.

What Doesn’t Change

While the new safe harbor is welcome news, it doesn’t mean trustees can simply accept every appraisal without asking questions.

The fiduciary responsibilities under ERISA remain exactly the same.

That means a trustee still needs to:

  • Hire a qualified, independent valuation professional.
  • Make sure the appraiser receives complete and accurate information.
  • Read the valuation report carefully.
  • Ask questions when assumptions or conclusions don’t make sense.
  • Document the review and decision-making process.

The law protects trustees who exercise diligence and act in good faith—not trustees who simply rubber-stamp an appraisal.

Lower Liability Risk

Perhaps the biggest benefit is greater legal certainty.

Historically, trustees have worried that years after a transaction closed, regulators could challenge the valuation using standards that weren’t clearly defined when the deal occurred.

The Retire Through Ownership Act reduces that uncertainty.

When an independent appraiser follows Revenue Ruling 59-60, and the trustee performs proper fiduciary oversight, demonstrating “adequate consideration” becomes much more straightforward.

That should provide trustees with significantly greater confidence during transactions.

The DOL Still Has a Role

The legislation doesn’t remove the Department of Labor from the picture.

The DOL still has authority to issue regulations related to the Act.

However, the law does place limits on that authority. It doesn’t expand the Department’s regulatory powers or allow future administrations to create entirely new valuation standards that undermine the safe harbor established by Congress.

For trustees, that’s another welcome layer of predictability.

Why This Matters Beyond Individual Transactions

The impact of this legislation reaches well beyond reducing litigation risk.

For years, many experienced professionals and institutional trust companies have been reluctant to serve as ESOP trustees because of the potential liability.

Greater legal clarity should encourage more qualified fiduciaries to participate in the ESOP marketplace.

Business owners may also feel more comfortable considering an ESOP as an exit strategy. With a clearer valuation process, transactions are likely to become more efficient, less costly, and potentially easier to insure.

Ultimately, that’s good news for everyone involved in employee ownership.

What Trustees Should Do Next

Even with the new protections, now is a good time to review your valuation process.

Ask yourself:

  • Does your valuation firm clearly document its use of Revenue Ruling 59-60?
  • Are your engagement letters and reports consistent with the new law?
  • Are your meeting minutes demonstrating thoughtful review and active oversight?
  • Is your documentation strong enough to show you fulfilled your fiduciary responsibilities?

The safe harbor provides important protection, but good documentation remains one of your strongest safeguards.

A Long-Awaited Turning Point

For decades, ESOP trustees have operated in an environment where the rules often seemed uncertain and the risks difficult to predict.

The Retire Through Ownership Act represents a major shift toward clarity and consistency.

It doesn’t lessen the importance of being a careful fiduciary. Instead, it rewards trustees who follow a sound valuation process and make thoughtful, well-documented decisions.

That’s good news for trustees, good news for business owners, and most importantly, good news for the employee-owners whose retirement security depends on well-managed ESOPs.